Sand-colored stucco home with a terra-cotta tile roof, potted kumquat trees, and a trimmed lawn.

Market Insight Spotlights

Harbor Bay Landing Restaurants: Closures and What Remains Open

"I'm worried about what this means, if the owners are just letting it all fall apart." (Alameda Post)

That's Stephan Dumont, who lives near Harbor Bay Landing, talking to the Alameda Post about the shopping center most Bay Farm Island residents pass through at least once a week. He wasn't talking about a developer's bulldozer. He was talking about a floor.

If you've shopped at Harbor Bay Landing this year, you already know the surface version of this story: red tags on three restaurant doors in August, a pizza place that isn't coming back, a Mexican spot that may or may not be open again by the time you read this. The closures followed a redevelopment proposal the previous year that would have replaced the shopping center. The proposal was withdrawn in November 2025, and building and sewer issues were reported in 2026.

The Redevelopment Proposal and Its Withdrawal

In September 2025, a Burlingame-based development firm, True Life Companies, filed a preliminary application to tear down Harbor Bay Landing and replace it with 305 housing units, 217 for sale and 88 for rent, with a portion set aside as very low, low, and moderate income units. No retail was included in the plans. For an island where this plaza is the only shopping center, that detail mattered more than the unit count. Residents packed an October community meeting to press city officials for answers, and the pushback was pointed: this was the only place on Bay Farm to buy groceries or gas without crossing the bridge.

By November 21, 2025, True Life had formally withdrawn its preliminary application. Filed as PREPLN25-0029 with the city's Planning Division, the withdrawal is public record. Residents who'd shown up to that meeting reasonably assumed they'd won something.

Except the plaza didn't come out of 2025 unscathed. The Harbor Bay 76 gas station, sitting on the same property, was confirmed closed as of November 30, 2025, redevelopment or no redevelopment. The one thing everyone fought to protect went away anyway, just not as part of a demolition. It closed on its own schedule, for its own reasons, while attention was fixed on the housing fight.

What Actually Happened This Year

The Alameda Post reported the following timeline: After the redevelopment proposal had played out publicly, Code Enforcement issued a separate Notice of Violation over the general condition of the property: debris accumulation, peeling paint, graffiti, damaged pedestrian areas, potholes in the parking lot. That was January 2026. That same month, the Community of Harbor Bay Isle Owners' Association, the HOA representing the condos around the plaza's lagoon, first alerted the city's Public Works Department that raw sewage was leaking from Building 891, the structure housing La Val's Pizza, La Penca Azul, and China Villa Restaurant, into the shared lagoon behind it.

What followed reads less like an isolated accident and more like a slow-motion breakdown:

  • April 2026: Sewer repairs were completed, but without a permit.
  • Early June 2026: A La Val's employee fell through the kitchen floor. A second employee described the walk-in refrigerator door no longer closing because the floor beneath it had shifted.
  • Mid-June 2026: A crack appeared near the refrigerator's back door, described by an employee as one side sitting roughly two inches lower than the other.
  • Late June 2026: A second employee fell through the same weakened floor and was taken to Highland Hospital in Oakland. Owner Salem Kaileh closed the restaurant.
  • Early July 2026: CHBIOA told Public Works it wasn't convinced the sewage issue had actually been resolved. Follow-up inspections found a foul odor and material buildup along the flow line, exactly what the association had flagged months earlier.
  • August 4, 2026: The city red-tagged all three restaurants in the building after a 48-hour Notice of Violation went unaddressed. La Penca Azul and China Villa stopped operating. La Val's, already closed since June, stayed shuttered.
  • September 1, 2026: At a City Council meeting, Councilmember Tracy Jensen said she'd learned La Val's would not reopen.

Seven months passed between the first sewage report and the red tags. An unpermitted repair sat in the middle of that gap.

What's Actually Open Right Now

If you're trying to figure out where to get lunch, here's where things stand as of this month. Safeway, CVS, and Subway, the plaza's main anchors, were never part of this and remain open and unaffected. Angelfish, the Japanese restaurant in the center, along with the small gym, coffee shop, optometry office, and shipping counter, sit in different buildings and weren't touched by the Building 891 issues either. Leydecker Park and the branch library next door are unaffected as well.

Inside Building 891 itself: La Val's Pizza is confirmed closed permanently, per Councilmember Jensen's September 1 statement. La Penca Azul's Park Street location told the Post that its Harbor Bay outpost was inspected on September 1 and staff were hoping to reopen within the week, which means it may already be back by the time you're reading this. China Villa Restaurant's status wasn't addressed at that meeting, so if you're headed there, it's worth calling ahead before you make the trip.

For what it's worth to the people who worked there and not just the people who ate there: La Val's staff have been out of work since June. La Penca Azul's Park Street branch wasn't able to absorb the displaced Harbor Bay staff either. Small plazas like this one run on people who show up to the same counter for years, and this year has been rough on them specifically.

What Remains Unknown

Harbor Bay Landing's owners are listed as Harbor Bay Landing LLC out of Burlingame, and its property manager is Sequoia Commercial Group. The Alameda Post reported it couldn't reach Sequoia for comment on the restaurant closures. The redevelopment application is withdrawn, not replaced with any stated alternative.

The redevelopment proposal gave everyone a clear stake: keep the grocery store, keep the gas station, keep the only retail center on the island. There was a public meeting where residents could show up and say their piece. Since then, the timeline has included a reported unpermitted sewer repair, Notices of Violation, and restaurant closures.

Sandy Lance, who moved back to Bay Farm after years away, put it plainly to the Alameda Post: "All of the past food places are gone, it's pitiful." The restaurant closures are only part of the story. Her words reflect how deeply the closures have affected people who remember the plaza’s former restaurants.

If you live on Bay Farm, the thing worth keeping an eye on isn't whether La Penca Azul's chips and salsa come back next week, though we hope they do. It's what Harbor Bay Landing LLC plans for the property following the withdrawn redevelopment application and this year's Building 891 issues.

We'll keep watching this one, because it affects daily life on Bay Farm more than most zoning fights do. If you have questions about what's happening in Harbor Bay or anywhere else on the island, from the ground level rather than a spreadsheet, Friedrich Homes Group is a call away. Reach out anytime for a free home valuation or just to talk through what's changing in your corner of Alameda.

A Trusted Team For Every Move

Buying or selling a home is one of life's most important decisions. We provide the market knowledge, negotiation expertise, and support needed to help you move forward confidently. Together, we'll create a strategy built around your success.